AI analysis confirms that an £71,000 Caravaggio painting at Sotheby’s and the Metropolitan Museum of Art was deemed a copy, despite its historical revival. This controversial case highlights the enduring debate over authenticity, raising questions about artistic innovation and tradition. The painting, attributed to Caravaggio, was discovered in 2019 and sold for £96m, sparking debates over its origins. However, recent research challenges this consensus, revealing potential flaws in earlier interpretations. Experts argue that the Wildenstein version—a depiction of the lute player as a woman—has unique characteristics that contradict known Caravaggio techniques. Dr. Carina Popovici noted that 85% confidence in attribution is high, while others emphasize the rarity of his works. A new podcast explores the painting’s mystery, presenting insights from art historians and scholars. Meanwhile, the Badminton Lute Player, now in London, aims to enter a public collection as part of a landmark investment. The artwork’s provenance remains a focal point of art market speculation, with historical records suggesting possible influences from later artists.
