Whether you're making cookies, roasting meat and vegetables, or preparing sheet pan meals, choosing the right cookware is essential for achieving delicious results. While a roasting pan, baking tray, and baking dish may seem interchangeable, each serves a unique purpose in the kitchen. Let's dive into these kitchen essentials' unique features, pros and cons, cooking uses, and when to use each.
Roasting Pan
A roasting pan is a deep, rectangular or oval-shaped pan often equipped with a rack to elevate the food for even cooking and to collect drippings. Typically made of durable materials such as stainless steel, cast iron, or heavy-duty aluminium, roasting pans feature high sides and sturdy handles for easy maneuverability.
Pros:
- Deep sides and large capacity: Roasting pans feature high sides that prevent splattering and contain juices, and a generous capacity ideal for cooking more food with less time.
- Even heat distribution: The open design allows hot air to circulate freely, resulting in consistent browning and caramelisation of the ingredients.
- Easy cleanup: Many roasting pans come with non-stick coatings, ensuring hassle-free cleaning after cooking.
Cons:
- Limited versatility: Due to their deep sides, roasting pans may not be suitable for baking delicate items or achieving crispy textures.
- Storage Space: Due to their larger size and high sides, roasting trays may require more storage space than other cookware.
Cooking uses
Roasting pans are specifically designed for roasting large cuts of meat, poultry, or vegetables. The high sides and spacious interiors of a roasting pan can accommodate large portions of food and are great for capturing flavorful drippings that can be used to make delicious gravies or sauces.
When to Choose it
Choose a roasting pan when you need to roast substantial amounts of food, want to collect drippings for added flavour, or require a container that can withstand high heat. They are commonly used for special occasions, holiday meals, or cooking for many guests.
Roasting Pans We Love
Ready to make roast veggies or a Sunday roast chicken? We've listed some of our best selling roasting pans below.
If you're looking for a high quality nonstick roasting pan large enough to combine meat and veggies, check out the Scanpan Classic Large Roasting Pan. This roasting pan has a Stratanium non-stick cooking surface and a pressure-cast aluminium base for superior heat distribution & retention. This roasting pan is able to fit a full turkey with ample space for vegetables. This is also an affordable option that doesn't compromise on quality.
If you prefer a stainless steel roasting pan, one of our best sellers also from Scanpan is the Scanpan Impact Roasting Pan. This stainless steel roaster has a special rim design that allows for drip-free pouring and also comes with a wire roasting rack. With cast stainless steel handles that stay cooler longer, the interior is made from mirror polished 18/10 stainless steel for maximum durability and stain resistance.
Another best seller from one of our favourite brands, Le Creuset is the Toughened Non-Stick Roasting Pan. Part of Le Creuset's TNS range, this non-stick pan is tough and durable with a hard anodised, heavy gauge aluminium body with 6-layer construction designed to last a lifetime. This roasting pan is also suitable for all cooktops, including induction and cast iron stoves.
Both Scanpan Roasting Pans and Le Creuset Roasting Pans ensure consistently delicious results every time.
Baking Tray
A baking tray, also known as a baking sheet or cookie sheet, is a flat, shallow, and sometimes rimless tray with a large surface area. Typically made of metal, aluminium, or non-stick material, baking trays feature a smooth surface that promotes even heat distribution.
Pros:
- Flat surface: Baking trays offer a flat and even cooking surface, ensuring uniform heat distribution and consistent browning for items like cookies, pastries, and pizzas.
- Versatility: Baking trays are perfect for roasting vegetables, toasting nuts, or reheating leftovers.
- Space-saving: Their thin profile allows for easy stacking and convenient storage.
Cons:
- Limited depth: Baking trays typically have low or no sides, which may not be suitable for dishes containing liquid or those that need to retain their shape during cooking.
Cooking Uses
Baking trays are perfect for baking cookies, biscuits, pastries, and other flat items that require consistent browning. They are also great for roasting vegetables, toasting nuts or seeds, or preparing sheet pan meals.
When to Choose it
Choose a baking tray when you need a large surface area for spreading out ingredients, want to achieve crispy textures, or prefer a versatile tool for everyday baking tasks. Baking trays are also often a go-to choice for quick and easy recipes or when you want a convenient one-pan solution for cooking multiple ingredients together.
Baking Trays We Love
When it comes to baking, we love the Mastercraft Professional Vitreous Enamel Baking Tray 39cm. This versatile vitreous enamel tray is designed with precision and care to ensure your baked goods turn out perfectly every time. From mouth watering cookies and brownies to savoury roasted vegetables and crispy chicken wings, this tray can handle it all. With its even heat distribution and superior heat retention, your culinary creations will be a hit! Plus, it's scratchproof and food-safe, giving you peace of mind.
If you’re craving smaller batches of cookies, adorable mini pastries, or simply reheating leftovers, the Mastercraft Baking Tray at 18cm fits the bill perfectly. The heavy-duty carbon steel construction ensures even heat distribution, allowing you to expect perfectly baked treats every time. Featuring the Quantum2 dual-layer non-stick coating, food releases from the tray easily, and cleaning is a breeze! Dishwasher, fridge and freezer safe, this PFOA and PTFE-free baking tray is also rust resistant, a must-have for any kitchen.
If you want fuss-free baking, this 35cm Bakemaster Baking Tray is sure to please! Crafted from heavy-duty carbon steel with rolled edges, this baking tray is sturdy and prevents warping. Bake, roast, or heat your favourite pastries effortlessly without worrying about food sticking, thanks to the double non-stick coating. PFOA, PTFE, and BPA-free, fridge, freezer and dishwasher-safe, this tray is also oven safe up to 260 degrees for optimal convenience.
Baking Dish
A baking dish is a versatile kitchen tool typically made of glass or ceramic. It features deeper sides and comes in various shapes, such as rectangular, square, or round. Baking dishes are oven-safe and designed to handle a range of sweet and savoury dishes.
Pros:
- Various shapes and sizes: Baking dishes come in various shapes and sizes, offering options for different recipes and serving portions.
- Aesthetic appeal: Ceramic or glass dishes can be used as elegant serving ware, taking your dishes from the oven to the dining table.
- Heat retention: Ceramic and glass dishes retain heat well, keeping your meals warm for extended periods.
Cons:
- Longer preheating time: Ceramic and glass dishes usually require longer preheating times compared to metal trays.
- Fragility: Ceramic and glass dishes can be delicate and prone to break.
Cooking Uses
Perfect for baking casseroles, lasagnas, gratins, and other layered dishes requiring longer cooking, baking dishes are also great for desserts like brownies, fruit crumbles, or bread puddings, providing a deep and reliable vessel for your sweet creations.
When to Choose it
Baking dishes are reliable and versatile cookware for oven-baked meals. They are particularly useful for meal prepping, as they allow you to make large batches of food that can be reheated and enjoyed throughout the week.
Baking Dishes We Love
Discover our favourite baking dishes that will elevate your baking endeavours.
Whether baking delicious loaves, bread, or meatloaf, or even using it as a convenient lunchbox, this multifunctional GlassLock Oven Safe Tempered Glass Rectangular Loaf Baker delivers outstanding performance. Made from high-quality, non-toxic BPA-free glass, these containers are fridge, freezer, dishwasher, and microwave safe. With its stackable design for easy storage and stain-resistant, non-reactive properties, it's the perfect addition to your kitchen arsenal.
If you’re cooking for a dinner party, the Pyrex Easy Grab Oblong Baking Dish Set is perfect. Crafted from durable Pyrex glass, these baking dishes are perfect for creating mouthwatering lasagnas, baked pasta, casseroles, and more. The non-porous surface ensures no odours or stains are absorbed, keeping them fresh and clean for every use. With easy-carry handles and dishwasher-safe convenience, cleanup is a breeze. These dishes are also safe for refrigerator, microwave, and pre-heated oven use. Proudly made in the USA, they come with a 2-year limited warranty.
Enjoy a cosy home cooked meal in style with the Staub Ceramic Gratin Rectangular Baking Dish in blue. This versatile 34cm dish is perfect for creating family-sized pasta dishes, brownies, cakes, and more. Carefully crafted in France, this baking dish features a durable glass porcelain finish and is twice-fired to ensure exceptional performance and scratch resistance. With its thermal shock resistance and oven-to-table functionality, cooking and serving your food creations is a simple task.
For those looking for durability and style, the Falcon Enamel Baking Dish in a stunning black and white speckle design is sure to please! This enamelware baking dish is crafted with porcelain and heavy-gauge steel, making it oven and dishwasher-safe. From lasagnas to gratins, effortlessly bake and serve your favourite dishes with elegance and ease. Resistant to chemicals and designed for everyday use, this dish is a timeless addition to your kitchen.
Want to see more? Explore our extensive range of high-quality roasting pans, baking trays, and baking dishes from renowned brands, including Le Creuset, Pyrex, Scanpan, Staub, and more!
Next Read: The Best Non-Stick Frypans in 2022
